Juvenile Fiction
October 13, 2015
384
When fifteen-year-old Julia Epstein and her Anglophone family flee Montreal in October 1970, she struggles to adjust to a new life in the suburban wasteland of North York, Toronto. Next door lives Carla Cabrielli, who works her "assets" and knows how to get what she wants. Julia and Carla get on a collision course, not only for the same role in the school production of "Hamlet," but also for the leading man - sword-wielding bad boy and sex magnet, Ian Slater. "Heartache and Other Natural Shocks" explores teen rivalry. When events take a dangerous turn, both Julia and Carla become vulnerable to deception and betrayal. Full of unexpected twist and turns, Glenda Leznoff's unique novel marks the debut of an important new voice in young-adult fiction.
Review:
“Heartache and Other Natural Shocks” is a coming-of-age story that is very deep and original. With a tone of dark realism, it is far from what I was expecting, and most definitely not a typical realistic fiction young adult novel.
The story is told between the alternating points-of-view of Julia Epstein and Carla Cabrielli. Julia has just been forced to relocate from Quebec to Toronto due to the political climate in 1971 Quebec. She’s a deep and flawed character, who is smart for her age but also naive when it comes to the things going on around her. She is also Jewish, and I seldom find Jewish protagonists, so I am always glad when I do. Carla is the stereotypical mean-girl on the surface, but reading between her words there is much more to be found in her character. The secondary characters, including the adults, are also all well-developed and engaging.
The author did an excellent job of establishing a sense of time and place without making it the primary focus of any particular scene. It was interesting to read about the political upheaval present in 1970s Quebec, which is a subject I have only come across briefly before. As for the rest of the plot, it is slow but engaging and does an excellent job of showing that the years may change but problems stay the same. Bullies will always exist, and the shock of parental failures will never lessen.
“Heartaches and Other Natural Shocks” is not going to be for everyone. It’s dark and depressing, so if you want a feel good book, pass it by. For those in high school and above looking for a thought-provoking read, and who don’t mind the darkness, I highly recommend it.
This review is based upon a complimentary copy provided by the publisher in exchange for an honest review.
Content Warning:
Language, Sexual Situations, Violence, Drug and Alcohol Abuse, Ethnic, Homophobic, and Sexual Slurs
